Time and Space Science — homeTimeAndSpace.Science

Snow line

Why aren’t the inner planets gas giants?

Close to the Sun it was too warm for ice and light gas to stick. The inner four could only build from rock and metal, so they stayed small. Past a line called the snow line, ice piled on, gravity grabbed hydrogen and helium, and the giants grew huge. The solar system simulator still shows that split: four small inner worlds, then a jump.

Sun velocity gravity no gravity — a straight line planet
Inside the snow line: rock. Outside it: ice and gas, and the mass to hold them. The jump between Mars and Jupiter is that line, later.

A temperature line in the disc

In the disc around the young Sun, water was vapour close in and ice farther out. Rock could stick either side of that line. Ice could not stick inside it. So the inner four grew from rock and metal only, and never got massive enough to hold a thick envelope of hydrogen.

Outside the line, ice was extra building material. More mass, more gravity, and those worlds could pull in the leftover gas before the Sun blew it away. Jupiter and Saturn won that race. Uranus and Neptune got there later and grabbed less gas, which is why they are ice giants rather than hydrogen balls.

Get more on this

The missing super-Earth

Planets between the size of Earth and Neptune are the commonest kind found around other stars, and our system does not have one. There is a gap between Earth and Neptune where most systems put their most typical planet. Jupiter’s early drift is the usual explanation. It is a model, not a photograph of the past.

See it live

On the hub: Space

💡 Question, problem or idea? Tell us →

Ask us anything about the tools, tell us what's broken or confusing, or suggest something we're missing. Every message is read by a person.

If you are under 13, do not send us your name, email, or any other personal information. If you are under 18, please get a parent or guardian's permission before using this form.

If you leave an email we'll reply to questions. We can't promise to build every suggestion, but they directly shape what we work on next.